Reports and Software on Utility and Large Boiler NOx Control Technologies.

 

“An essential reference for anyone living with SCR systems.”

 

Andover Technology Partners has developed:

Selective Catalytic Reduction Technology -

Operating Principles

Operating Guidelines

Troubleshooting Guide

It is intended to be a useful reference document for power plant managers, engineers, and operators, especially those operating SCR systems on coal-fired boilers.  It ties together experience on SCR technology, especially on US coals, and provides advice on lessons that have been learned from operators throughout the US, abroad, and advice from SCR technology and catalyst suppliers.  The report also comes with a worksheet that is useful for performing calculations and budget projections.

 

The price for a single copy of the SCR Report when purchased individually is $2,750 plus shipping/handling.  Discounts apply for multiple orders or for orders combined with purchase of the CAT MANAGER.  Contact us for pricing on Enterprise Licenses (may be installed on a server) or Multiple-User Licenses.  Go to this link (Purchase SCR Report) for information on how to purchase a user’s license for the document and the worksheets. 

 

Andover Technology Partners will also release a document on Selective Non Catalytic Reduction (SNCR) technology in the coming weeks.

 

Read further for the Table of Contents for the SCR report.

 

Selective Catalytic Reduction Technology

Operating Principles

Operating Guidelines

Troubleshooting Guide

 


Andover Technology Partners has written a document to assist engineering managers and operators more effectively manage their SCR plants.  It includes over sixty figures, including color photos of equipment and service/maintenance activities.  The Table of Contents, List of Figures and List of Tables is shown.

 

Part 1 Selective Catalytic Reduction for NOx Control of Large Boilers

 

1.1     Introduction

1.2 Post Combustion NOx Control Technologies for Boilers – General

1.3  Selective Catalytic Reduction – Principles of Operation and General Description of Hardware

1.3.1 SCR Process Chemistry

1.3.2  SCR System Description

1.3.3  SCR Hardware Components

 

1.4  Reagent Storage and Handling

1.4.1  Anhydrous Ammonia

Chemical Specification

1.4.2  Aqueous Ammonia

Chemical Specification

1.4.3 Urea

   Chemical Specification

 

1.5  Effects of Ammonia and Gas Distribution on Performance

1.5.1  Ammonia and Flue Gas Distribution

Calculating Coefficient of Variation

1.5.2 Ammonia Injection Methods

AIGs and Associated Ammonia Distribution Hardware

Nozzle Plugging

Static Mixers combined with AIGs

Adjusting the Ammonia Distribution

1.5.3 Controlling and Preserving the Flowfield Through the SCR Reactor and Ductwork

Turning Vanes, Dummy Catalyst, and General Ductwork

Cleaning Dust Off Line

On-Line Dust Cleaning

Popcorn Slag

Dampers

Damper Failures

Expansion joints

 

1.6 Catalyst

1.6.1 Typical Catalyst Composition

Selecting a Catalyst

Experience, Poison Resistance and Coal Quality (General)

Pressure Drop, Price, Lifetime and Other factors (General)

1.6.2  Catalyst Management

Regeneration of Catalyst

Evaluating Catalyst Management Strategies

Taking Samples for Monitoring the Catalyst Material

Adding and Replacing Catalyst

Installing a New Layer of Catalyst

Removing and Replacing Installed catalyst-

1.6.3 Catalyst Poisoning/Deactivation

Ash – Short-Term Deactivation

Long-Term Catalyst Deactivation Mechanisms

Calcium Sulfate Formation

Arsenic Poisoning

The problem with US Coals

U.S. Experience with Arsenic Deactivation

Arsenic Measurement in Coal

Options For Units Experiencing Arsenic Deactivation

Implications for Facilities Burning East Bit. Coal

Alkaline Materials

Sulfur Effects and Considerations

Additive Injection

Measuring SO3

 

 

 

1.7Controls and Instrumentation

Purpose of the Control System

NOx Analyzers

 

1.8 Ammonia Slip

1.8.1 Deposition of ammonia salts

Managing Air Preheater Pressure Drop Buildup

Air Preheater Designs for Lower Depositon

1.8.2 Ammonium Chloride Plume

1.8.3 Measuring Ammonia Slip

Wet Chemical Method

Monitoring Ammonia in Fly Ash

Continuous analyzer methods

 

1.9 Start Up, Shut Down, and Maintenance Schedules

1.9.1  Start Up

SCR Reactor Heat Up
Pressure and Flow Transients

Admitting Ammonia

1.9.2 Shut Down of the SCR

Lay Up of the Catalyst Reactor

1.9.3 Maintenance Schedules

Maintenance of the SCR System

Part 2: Troubleshooting Guide

2.1 Problems That Can Cause High Ammonia Slip

2.1.1  Symptoms

High ammonia slip measurement

Imbalanced Ammonia Distribution

Reactor flow imbalances

Catalyst deactivation

Ammonia Flowrate Control

Bypass Damper Leakby

Temperature

Burner Problems

 

2.2  Causes of Poor NOx Reduction

2.2.1   Symptoms

Bypass Leakage

Controls

Reagent

Other Problems

 

2.3 SO3-related problems

Plume

Corrosion or Pluggage of Air Preheaters

 

2.4 Pressure Drop Problems

High pressure drop across the SCR reactor

Low pressure drop across the SCR reactor

High pressure drop across the air preheater

High pressure drop across AIG

 

Part 3.  SCR Analysis Worksheet

Inputs

Outputs

Input Data Table

Input Data Table (con’t)

Outputs – Reactor View

Outputs – Process Analysis

Outputs – Catalyst Addition/Replacement (Chart)

Outputs – Cash Flow Analysis

Outputs – First Year Costs (Before

Tax Basis)

Outputs – Before Tax Operating

Cash Flows of SCR (Chart)

 

 

 

 

Figure 1.  Temperature window of SCR reaction

Figure 2.   Reduction in catalyst activity and ammonia on fly ash

Figure 3.  Gas path for coal-fired boiler with High-Dust SCR, ESP and FGD

.

Figure 4.  SCR installation at PP&L Montour #2
Figure 5.  An example of an aqueous ammonia storage and vaporization system

Figure 6.  AOD™ urea to ammonia conversion system

Figure 7.  An example of a U2A system

Figure 8.  Increased catalyst volume requirement due to maldistribution of ammonia, gas flow and temperature

Figure 9.  Predicted NOx Reduction versus Velocity, Temperature, and Mole Ratio Coefficient of Variation

Figure 10.  The use of guide vanes and a mixing system on predicted face velocity distribution at the first catalyst layer

Figure 11.  Predicted NOx Reduction versus Velocity, Temperature, and Mole Ratio Coefficient of Variation 

Figure 12  Schematic of SCR system showing static mixer, turning vanes, ammonia injection grid (AIG), and flow straightener for gas flow control

Figure 13.  An Ammonia Injection Grid (AIG) with upstream and downstream turbulence generators

Figure 14.  Dilution Air, Ammonia Control and Distribution Manifolds for Control of Ammonia among AIG nozzles

Figure 15.  AIG with various controlled zones for spatial control of ammonia

Figure 16.  AIG with preheating to avoid ammonium bisulfate formation on nozzle tips

Figure 17.  Babcock Borsig Delta Wing™ Ammonia Distribution

Figure 18.  Delta Wing™ and ammonia injection for 630 MW boiler

Figure 19.  Photo of Delta Wing™ assembly being put into place on a utility boiler

Figure 20.  SCR Reactor with 7 x 3 zone AIG

Figure 21a.  AIG Control Zones for a 7x3 zone AIG

Figure 21b.  SCR exit measurement points and corresponding AIG control zones with two measurement points per zone

Figure 22.  Unoptimized and Optimized Flow with Turning Vanes and Flow Straightener

Figure 23.  Dust deposition and erosion of catalyst downstream of a turn with unoptimized flow

Figure 24.  Dust deposition and catalyst erosion resulting from flow disturbances

Figure 25.  Deposits on unoptimized guide vane

Figure 26.  Dust deposition in honeycomb flow straightener

Figure 27.  Dust deposits on honeycomb flow straightener

Figure 28.  Severely eroded honeycomb catalyst

Figure 29.  Unoptimized Reactor, showing heavy deposits

Figure 30.  Optimized Reactor, showing light deposits

Figure 31.  A Rake-Style Soot Blower used for catalyst cleaning

Figure 32.  Estimated ammonia slip if injected ammonia leaks by SCR reactor through bypass and ammonia is increased to compensate for leakby

Figure 33.  Estimated effect of SCR reactor leakby on NOx and ammonia slip if ammonia injection is not increased to compensate for leakby

Figure 34.  Effect of pressure and gravity on large louver dampers that may cause distortion, leakage, and possible mechanical failure due to flexing and stresses

 

Figure 35.  Plate and Honeycomb Catalyst

Figure 36. A catalyst module containing steel plate catalyst

Figure 37. A catalyst module containing ceramic honeycomb catalyst

Figure 38.  Installation of Catalyst Modules, showing Baffle Plates

Figure 39.  Catalyst reactor sized for up to three levels with two layers per level

Figure 40a. Catalyst activity vs operating time for SCR of Fig. 13 using a catalyst management plan that only replaces catalyst

Figure 40b.  Catalyst activity vs operating time for SCR of Fig. 13 using a catalyst management plan that initially adds catalyst and then replaces catalyst

Figure 41.  SCR Reactor being evaluated in Figures 42 a through 42 h.

Figures 42 a through h. Analysis of different catalyst management scenarios for an SCR reactor

Figure 43.  Extracting Catalyst Plates from an Element   

Figure 44.  Structural Steel and Sealing Strips for Catalyst Module

Figure 45.  Reactor catalyst level top view

Figure 46.  Lowering the catalyst module from the temporary hoist on the hydraulic trolley.

Figure 47.  Pushing the catalyst module to the final position

Figure 48.  Plate catalyst modules on support beams in a top-supported reactor.

Figure 49.  Final installation of baffle plates between modules and reactor wall

Figure 50.  Lambda for Stable versus Increasing Deactivation Rates

Figure 51.  k/ko for Stable versus Increasing Deactivation Rates

Figure 52.  Calcium Sulfate Formation in Catalyst Microstructure

Figure 53. Deactivation of a honeycomb catalyst by gaseous arsenic

Figure 54. Arsenic in Ash versus CaO in Ash for a variety of US Coals

Figure 55.  The fate of Arsenic in a Coal Fired Boiler

Figure 56.  Concentrating Mechanism in Wet Bottom Boiler with Fly Ash Reinjection

Figure 57.  Effect of limestone addition on gaseous arsenic level

Figure 58.  Effect of limestone addition on gaseous arsenic level on three different boilers with fly ash reinjection

Figure 59.  Estimated Gaseous Arsenic Concentration Based on OUC Stanton design coal and combustion air flows

Figure 60.  Effect of Catalyst V2O5 content on SOx conversion and NOx reduction activity

Figure 61.  Example of Control System, showing monitored parameters and Feed Forward and Feed Back Control

Figure 62.  SCR Plant and Component Design Instrumentation Flanges

Figure 63.  Gas and APH Temperatures

Figure 64.  Ammonium Sulfate (AS) and Ammonium BiSulfate Formation (ABS) Temperatures

Figure 65  Ammonium Bisulfate Depostion in a Lungstrom Air Preheater

Figure 66.  Logan Station APH Gas-Side Pressure Drop Trend

Figure 67.  Notched Fixed and Double Undulated Air Preheater Elements

Figure 68.  Recommended Minimum Temperatures/Maximum Humidity for Layup of Catalyst

 

 

Table 1.              Product Gases of U2A™ Process

Table 2.              Coefficient of Variation Calculation for a 3x5 array of points

Table 3.              Mechanisms for Catalyst Deactivation by Arsenic and Methods to Mitigate Deactivation

Table 4.              Coal Arsenic Concentration Measurements On As Delivered Coal For OUC Stanton #2 for sample taken October 13, 1998

 

Table 5.              Measured CaO in As-Delivered Coal Ash

Table 6               Arsenic Measurement In Coal - Recommended Methods

Table 7.              Technologies for Continuous Measurement From Ammonia

Table 8a             Inspection Procedures for the SCR System

Table 8b             Inspection Procedures for the SCR System

Table 8c             Inspection Procedures for the SCRSystem


 

 


The document and associated Boiler SCR process analysis worksheets are available under license agreement from Andover Technology Partners.  Worksheets run on Windows 95/98/2000/NT/XP computers with Microsoft Excel.

 

Go to this link (Purchase SCR Report) for information on how to purchase a user’s license for the document and the worksheets.


 

Process Analysis Worksheet

 

With the Excel worksheet that is provided with the document, process calculations are performed, projections of cash flows associated with the SCR system can be developed, and estimated cost of control that may be useful in emissions trading scenarios are also possible.

 


 

 

Process Analysis

 

 

 

 

Boiler SCR

 

 

 

 

MMBTU/hr

4,000

 

 

 

lb/hr NOx reduced (full load)

1,620

 

 

 

lbmole/hr NOx reduced

35

 

 

 

Pri. Fuel Cost, $/MMBTU

$1.50

 

 

 

Pri. Fuel Cost, $/hr

$6,000

 

 

 

Reagent (Ammonia or Urea)

 

 

 

 

   Ammonia usage (lbmole/hr)

35.2

 

 

 

   Ammonia usage (lb/hr)

598.70

 

 

 

   Anhydrous Ammonia Cost ($/hr)

$74.84

 

 

 

 Urea usage (lbmole/hr)

17.6

 

 

 

 Urea usage (lb/hr)

1056.52

 

 

 

 Urea cost ($/hr)

$79.24

 

 

 

 Energy Consumption

 

 

 

 

  Anhyd. Ammonia Vaporization

0.38

MMBTU/hr

 

 

  Aqua Ammonia Water Vaporization

2.94

MMBTU/hr

 

 

  AOD  heat input

4.19

MMBTU/hr

 

 

  U2A heat input

3.29

MMBTU/hr

 

 

  U2A water usage

1,057

lb/hr

 

 

 

127

gal/hr

 

 

Initial Catalyst Loading (m3)

480

 

 

 

Full Load Flow Rate (ACFM)

1,934,370

 

 

 

Pressure Drop Power Consumption

1,894

KW

 

 

Uncontrolled NOx

0.450